Paying for Car Insurance? Martin Lewis Tip Could Put £240 Back in Your Pocket

UK drivers could potentially save hundreds of pounds on their car insurance by avoiding automatic renewal and comparing prices before their existing policy expires.

Martin Lewis has repeatedly warned motorists not to assume that a renewal quote is a good deal. A recent MoneySavingExpert success story showed one driver saving £240 over a year after comparing alternative quotes and then returning to her existing insurer.

Don’t automatically accept your renewal price

Your insurer will normally send a renewal quote before your policy ends. Even if the new price looks reasonable, it is worth checking what other insurers are offering.

MoneySavingExpert’s latest guidance says drivers should never simply auto-renew without comparing prices. Prices can vary between insurers, and the cheapest option is not necessarily the same provider you used previously.

Try the 22-to-26-day rule

One of the most useful tips is to avoid leaving your insurance comparison until the last minute.

MoneySavingExpert analysed hundreds of thousands of quotes from February to April 2026 and found that buying cover around 22 to 26 days before renewal was cheapest on average, with 25 days producing the lowest average price.

The analysis found an average annual premium of £374 when bought 25 days ahead, compared with £708 on the renewal date — a difference of £334. However, these are averages, and individual savings can be very different.

Compare more than one site

Checking just one comparison website may not give you the cheapest available option.

MSE recommends comparing across at least two comparison sites because insurers can offer different prices or may not appear on every comparison service.

Once you have found a competitive quote, you can also contact your existing insurer and ask whether it can match or beat the price.

Check the cover, not just the price

The cheapest policy is not automatically the best one. Before switching, check the excess, level of cover, courtesy-car arrangements, breakdown cover and other optional extras.

Most importantly, make sure every detail you provide is accurate. Changing information simply to obtain a cheaper quote could leave you inadequately insured.

£240 is possible, but not guaranteed

The £240 saving is based on a real recent example, not a fixed discount available to every driver.

Your potential saving will depend on your age, vehicle, location, driving history, claims record and policy requirements.

Still, spending a little time comparing quotes before renewal could help prevent you from paying more than necessary for your next year’s cover.

Leave a Comment